Skip to content

Neither Straw nor Cardboard

September 11, 2012

“Neither Straw nor Cardboard” James 1:17-27 © 9/9/12 Ordinary 23B by Tom Cheatham at First Presbyterian Church, Amory, MS. All rights reserved.

The 16th-century reformer Martin Luther famously observed that reading the book of James was like eating straw. His exact words were that it was a “right strawy epistle.” In other words, a document not fit for human consumption, without appeal and of no value. If Luther lived today, he might instead comment that James tasted like cardboard, as in that commercial where shoppers wonder if a fiber cereal can be palatable, whatever nutrition it offers.

Reviews from others ancient and modern have been mixed. The early church father named Origen quoted James about two dozen times in his works. Jerome, on the other hand, rather grudgingly included it in his Latin translation of the Bible known as the Vulgate. The assessment of James’s value across the Church East and West was so iffy that it took about 300 years after it was written for the book to finally be included in the Bible (in the late 4th century).

A good many contemporary scholars have often followed Luther in dismissing James. John Shelby Spong, for example, devotes barely a page to it in his book Reclaiming the Bible for a Non-Religious World. “I find the epistle of James to be of value,” he says, “but not of great value.” He does credit it with inspiring charitable work with the poor, and thus deems it worthy to be included in the New Testament (174).

Luther’s problem with the book came from his fierce devotion to justification by faith and his misunderstanding of what James has to say about the subject. The reformer thought the author was claiming we are made right with God by our works, in direct contradiction to Paul’s celebration of the gift of salvation by grace.

In fact, whatever the conflicts between the historical James and Paul, there is no disagreement between this book and Paul’s position. Paul was talking about something different than James. It’s apples and oranges. Both see salvation as a gift. What James is interested in is not the concepts of law and grace or how people are saved. He’s talking to Christians about living authentically, proving their profession by their way of life.

So who was James, and why should we pay attention to him? The answer to the first part is that he was Jesus’ brother, presumably next born after our Lord. We’re told in 1 Corinthians that Jesus appeared to James after his resurrection. James would eventually become a prominent leader in the Jerusalem branch of the Church. The historian Josephus reports that he was stoned to death by the religious authorities for sins against the Jewish law in the early 60s of the first century. If our Lord’s brother actually wrote the book, then it would predate the gospels and be contemporary with Paul’s undisputed letters. If the book was penned in James’ name, which was a common practice back in the day, it was written about 90 AD, around the same time as the Gospel of John and Revelation.

Now about the second question. We should pay attention to James first of all because he speaks with the same voice as Jesus. This collection of essays isn’t concerned with doctrines and rituals and principles. It’s about the same kinds of things our Lord found important. Relationships. Caring for the vulnerable. Speaking and acting. Being real. Endurance and integrity. In fact, the closeness in content between James and the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew is striking. The order is different than in Matthew, so James may be taking us back to the source for both his collection and the gospel. Indeed, James takes us closer to Jesus than Matthew, since his letter was written perhaps even decades before the gospel. This book gets at the heart of Jesus’ ethical teaching at its most uncomplicated, before it was shaped by the Church into doctrine, before it was overshadowed by ecclesiastical politics and bureaucracy.

Which brings us to the second reason we should pay attention to James. It’s a book for our age of many faiths and our awareness of wisdom from sources beyond our own tradition. This collection of teachings draws not only from Jesus, but from Jewish wisdom writings and from Greek philosophers. Actually, all those simply inhabited a common universe of thought and practice and respected each other. James also uses methods of teaching that were popular and considered effective in his day. In good wisdom fashion and like Jesus, he draws his examples from everyday life, teaching us that if we simply look around we will find spiritual lessons. Finally, he talks about God more than specifically about Christ. That makes him a resource for anyone who affirms the reality of One beyond us and to whom we are grateful and accountable, no matter what we may call that Being.

The takeaway for us in our divided day of disrespectful, “I’ve got the only truth” speech is that we don’t have to be afraid to acknowledge that somebody is right and honorable and worthy who doesn’t share our perspective on politics or religion. We don’t need to close our ears to good teaching and to helpful ideas just because they come from somewhere outside our circle, our ideological camp, our community of faith. Christians don’t need to be afraid of or reject the insights of science or Muslims or Buddhists or Jews in order somehow to preserve the integrity of our confession. Republicans and Democrats and independents and Libertarians can cooperate and collaborate and celebrate instead of being mired in the partisan bickering and outright hatred that characterizes so much of today’s discourse and dysfunction. Everyone can and should be careful about matters of speech and hospitality and justice.

But even though James reminds us of the simple teachings of Jesus and urges us to listen to each other, those are not the most important reasons to pay attention to him. Here it is: James invites us to view the world, our lives, our neighbors as gifts. That’s at the root of everything he says. God is the faithful, constant, trustworthy giver of gifts, the Source of light and good and help. When you and I believe that, our outlook on everything is transformed. When we see all we have and are and will become as gifts, our role is to steward those gifts. We begin to understand that there is enough for me and you and everyone because God doesn’t know how to stop giving. He is gracious and loving and desires for us the liberty of people who don’t need to grasp at life, don’t need to shut out our neighbors, don’t need to compete and hurt and defraud in order to have what we need to live. God’s purpose for us is that of a loving parent who has granted us all we need to live not just now but forever.

The alternative is what we see so often in the churches, in business, the family, in politics. That view says that if you get yours, then I won’t have mine, because there’s not enough to go around. The world, the universe, is ultimately out to get us and shortchange us, so I have to grab everything I can for me and mine or I won’t survive. It’s an arrogant, hateful attitude that assumes conflict and war and scarcity as the norm. It scoffs at the idea of grace and refuses to be gracious and hospitable. Such is the fruit of the rank growth of wickedness James talks about.

For such people, “God” is merely a concept, a slogan, a word that we say, a faint memory of something we once believed in, but now have emptied of any real content. God doesn’t define and shape our reality; we do, so this thinking goes. We are the measure of everything: our wants, our needs, our agendas. So we ignore our neighbors even as we use the name of God to justify and bless our viewpoints.

But no matter how much we say the words “God” and “Jesus,” our religion is a sham and worthless if it doesn’t issue in concrete action on behalf of the vulnerable, the voiceless, the left-out, the hurting, and the helpless. James says we’re deluded if we think that kind of faith is authentic. Faith for him is not assenting to ideas or mouthing the so-called right doctrine. It’s treating others as you want to be treated, loving your neighbor as yourself. It’s visiting the sick and taking care of the needy. It’s taming your tongue and listening while someone pours out their heart. It’s putting a rein on your rage and instead seeking to promote the righteousness of God. Not talk, talk, talk but act, act, act. Results, not resolutions. Ministry, not motions. Compassion, not callous disregard. Humble authenticity, not arrogant self-promotion.

James is neither straw nor cardboard. Instead, it’s tasty fare for mature believers, nourishment for the serious journey of faith.

Dig into it.


From → Uncategorized

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: